Shaza All articles
Life & Style

Blindfolds, Bourbons and Big Opinions: The Supermarket Taste-Off That's Replacing the Dinner Party

Shaza
Blindfolds, Bourbons and Big Opinions: The Supermarket Taste-Off That's Replacing the Dinner Party

Photo: friends blindfolded supermarket biscuit taste test kitchen table scoring cards, via tvseriesfinale.com

There is a specific sound that follows the first bite of a blind supermarket taste test. It is not a polite mmm. It is a confused grunt, a pause, then someone saying, 'That's a Richmond sausage, I'd bet my nan's teapot on it.' And they are almost always wrong. Welcome to the UK's best new night in: a cheap, silly, strangely competitive way to spend a Friday that involves own-brand biscuits, freezer-aisle classics and absolutely no need to clean the good glasses.

Why it beats an expensive dinner party

First, the maths. A dinner party for six can easily clear £60 before you've bought the wine, the candles or the replacement bulb for the bathroom. A supermarket taste test for six costs about £15 and the washing-up fits in one sink. Second, the social maths. Dinner parties ask people to perform: bring a nice bottle, say nice things, don't mention that the chicken is dry. A blind taste test asks people to argue about whether a chocolate digestive has 'good snap'. It is much easier to be interesting when you're not pretending to be elegant.

Food writer and recipe developer Priya Chohan has been running blind tastings with friends in Birmingham since early 2026. 'The brilliance is that it strips away branding and price,' she says. 'You can put a 45p custard cream next to a fancy shortbread and people genuinely lose their bearings. The conversation starts immediately. Nobody is talking about work.'

Host Sam Ellery, who runs a monthly taste-off in Leeds, says the format has replaced the dinner party for his group. 'We had one woman who works in finance nearly crying with laughter because she'd ranked a supermarket bourbon above a posh biscuit and then refused to accept it,' he says. 'Another friend brought a scoring spreadsheet. It has become a whole thing.'

The rules (and when to ignore them)

Keep it simple. Choose one category per round: biscuits, crisps, or freezer-aisle favourites. Buy five to seven items in the same broad family. For biscuits, that might mean plain digestives, chocolate digestives, custard creams, bourbons and a wildcard shortbread. For crisps, stick to ready salted or cheese and onion so you're comparing like with like. For the freezer round, mini sausage rolls, vegetable samosas, potato croquettes and those tiny pizza bagels are all fair game.

Decode the samples before anyone arrives. Put each item on a numbered plate or in a paper bag. Give everyone a scoring card with four columns: texture, flavour, value and 'would you buy it again?'. Score out of 10. No talking during the first bite. Then let the chaos begin.

You can blindfold people, but don't force it. A tea towel works. So does closing your eyes. The point is not to make anyone uncomfortable; the point is to make them stop reading the packaging. If you have a friend who can identify a Jaffa Cake by the sound of the chocolate cracking, put them on a team with someone who once described a Pringle as 'a bit much'.

The fake sommelier commentary is the secret weapon

This is where the night goes from nice to memorable. Encourage everyone to describe what they're eating as if they're on a very cheap episode of MasterChef. 'I'm getting notes of school cupboard and mild regret.' 'This bourbon has a top note of optimism and a finish of cardboard.' 'The custard cream is giving benign office nostalgia.'

It sounds daft, and it is. But pretending to be a sommelier gives people permission to be playful. Priya Chohan says the commentary is the bit guests remember. 'It's theatre without the price tag,' she says. 'You're not being mean about the food. You're being ridiculous about the food. There's a difference.'

A ready-to-run format for your first night

The shopping list (for six people, under £15)

Adjust for dietary needs. Check labels. Keep water on the table. Put out a bin bowl for crumbs and a stack of napkins that you pretend is generous.

The scoring card

Give each guest a printed sheet with five rows and four columns. Add a final question: 'Which one would you secretly buy again?' That last line is where the truth comes out.

The running order

Round one: biscuits. Round two: crisps. Round three: freezer. Reveal the brands only after everyone has scored. Tally the results. Award a prize that costs nothing: the title of Supermarket Sommelier, plus the right to choose the next round's category. If you want to make it a monthly thing, rotate hosts and keep a running leaderboard.

What to avoid

Don't turn it into a snobbery contest. The fun comes from treating a 60p biscuit with the same seriousness as a £4 one. Don't make people eat things they're allergic to. Don't blindfold anyone who doesn't want to be blindfolded. And don't reveal the answers halfway through, even if your mate Dave is insisting he can taste the difference between two identical digestives. He can't. That's the point.

By 11pm, you will have learned three things: which supermarket custard cream is genuinely the best, which friend has the most unreasonable crisp opinions, and that a night in can feel like an event without a single candle being lit. The best new night in isn't about the food. It's about the running commentary, the scoring cards and the moment someone takes off a blindfold and says, 'I can't believe I got that wrong.'

All Articles

Related Articles

The Takeaway Tea Walk Is the Best Social Plan Britain Has Invented Since the Picnic

The Takeaway Tea Walk Is the Best Social Plan Britain Has Invented Since the Picnic

The Tiny Radio Shows Making Prime-Time Telly Sound Rushed

The Tiny Radio Shows Making Prime-Time Telly Sound Rushed

Five Spoken-Word Acts Turning Quiet UK Rooms Into Big Nights Out

Five Spoken-Word Acts Turning Quiet UK Rooms Into Big Nights Out